Friday, February 22, 2008

Water cure

I just read the article in The New Yorker about the use of water torture (it was then called "water cure") by American troops in the Philippines at the turn of the century. The article ended with a quote from an article in the New York World on April 16, 1902, which described America's reaction to the torture:

It sips its coffee and reads of its soldiers administering the “water cure” to rebels; of how water with handfuls of salt thrown in to make it more efficacious, is forced down the throats of the patients until their bodies become distended to the point of bursting; of how our soldiers then jump on the distended bodies to force the water out quickly so that the “treatment” can begin all over again. The American Public takes another sip of its coffee and remarks, “How very unpleasant!”


“But where is that vast national outburst of astounded horror which an old-fashioned America would have predicted at the reading of such news?” the World asked. “Is it lost somewhere in the 8,000 miles that divide us from the scenes of these abominations? Is it led astray by the darker skins of the alien race among which these abominations are perpetrated? Or is it rotted away by that inevitable demoralization which the wrong-doing of a great nation must inflict on the consciences of the least of its citizens?”

1 comment:

jed dietz said...

For a slightly different perspective, readers should see TAXI TO THE DARK SIDE the Oscar-winning documentary about Bush era torture. It suggests something a little different than the New Yorker piece- that once upon a time, like in WW II, we decided not to torture.

It's made by the same guy, Alex Gibney, who made ENRON: THE AMARTEST GUYS IN THE ROOM.